Sign up with your email address to be the first to know about new products, VIP offers, blog features & more.

Light and Simple Bloody Marys


Light and Simple Bloody Marys

September in Indiana is a lot different than August in Indiana. Produce stands that were overflowing with tomatoes and corn two weeks ago are now hawking pumpkins, mums, and decorative bales of straw.

Around the first of September, Williams-Sonoma contacted us to ask if we would put our spin on the bloody mary using freshly juiced tomatoes. Our response went something like this: “Um – yes, we would LOVE to.” And our reward? Well, I think you can figure that out.

Light and Simple Bloody Marys

So, we went out to get tomatoes and we came back empty-handed 3 times. One would think that, in Indiana, when it’s still summer, it wouldn’t be hard to find organic tomatoes. WRONG. All of those quaint booths along our country roads were gone, “Poof!” Except one.

While we were driving our car home from the body shop [thanks to the luggage carrier that scuffed our roof on the road trip] we saw a beacon of hope. We skidded to a stop and u-turned down a short gravel road marked by signs promising kale, salsa, squash, and yes… TOMATOES. They did not disappoint. We brought home a sack full of tomatoes that weighed about 1/2 pound a piece and they were full of plenty of juice.

Until the Williams-Sonoma team put us up to the task, I had never considered making a bloody mary without using a mix. I don’t know why it never occurred to me because – this bloody mary is a prime example – everything is better when it’s made from scratch with quality ingredients.

Speaking of quality, I highly recommend using good vodka. Pass up the Smirnoff in favor of quality vodka – Van Gogh, Tito’s, American Harvest – you won’t be sorry. Quality liquor adds flavors, scents, and depth that take your cocktail from good to fantastic.

Ice in Glass Pouring

Light and Simple Bloody Marys

We don’t use our juicer anywhere near often enough, so this was the perfect opportunity to dust it off. We have an older model that isn’t made anymore, but it looks and operates very similar to several of the slow juicers that Williams-Sonoma has. Just browsing through their juicers prompted me to start working on my Christmas list. [Speaking of: Does anyone have a recommendation? I’d love to know what you use!]

When you juice tomatoes fresh, like we did for this cocktail, you know what to expect. The drink tastes like it was picked from the vine just hours before you sip it – because it was. Basil and fresh lemon create a bright crispness and horseradish adds the finishing bite that makes you say, “Ahhhh…”

Bloody Marys

My main concern before starting the juice was that it would turn out water-y and filter out too much of the tomato, but that wasn’t a problem at all. Even after being processed through the machine, plenty of the tomatoes’ substance comes through in the juice. That’s what you get when you invest in a quality juicer.

There is a time and a place for a heavy, filling bloody mary and this is not one of those times. This bloody mary? This one is for when you want to save room for brunch and when you need a late afternoon libation after one of summer’s remaining hot days. The heavy, overly garnished ones are meant for the dead of winter – and there’ll be plenty of time for drinking them then.

For now, let’s all enjoy the sun’s last few rays and the last fresh tomatoes we can get our hands on. Juice them, chill them, and combine them with quality vodka, then relax.

Bloody Mary

Bloody Marys


Light and Simple Bloody Marys

The lightest, most understated bloody mary you will ever taste, this cocktail is made with freshly juiced tomatoes, basil, and sharp horseradish.

  • Author: The Fitchen
  • Prep Time: 10 mins
  • Total Time: 10 mins
  • Yield: 4 1x
  • Category: Drinks


  • 4 large tomatoes
  • 1 large Roma tomato
  • 1/4 cup fresh basil
  • 1/2 Tablespoon sea salt
  • 3/4 teaspoon black pepper
  • 1/4 teaspoon cayenne pepper
  • 1/4 teaspoon chipotle powder
  • 3 Tablespoons horseradish
  • 1 Tablespoon lemon juice
  • 4 ounces of vodka


  1. Cut the tomatoes into quarters.
  2. Juicer: Run tomatoes through until you’re all out.
  3. Juicer: In a food processor or blender, mix juice, basil, and all seasonings except horseradish and lemon until well-combined.
  4. Juicer: Pour mixture into a pitcher and stir in lemon juice and horseradish.
  5. Blender or Food Processor: Add tomatoes, basil, and all seasonings except horseradish and lemon juice into the blender and process. If using a juicer, toss everything into a processor to combine the other ingredients.
  6. Blender or Food Processor: Pour mix through a mesh strainer to separate the liquid from the pulp. The remaining pulp can be used to make a tasty spaghetti sauce for dinner!
  7. Blender or Food Processor: Add horseradish and lemon juice to the mixture and stir in with a spoon.
  8. In a small dish or bowl, grind fresh black pepper – about 1 teaspoon or enough to rim your glasses. I don’t recommend salt because the tomato juice already has plenty of salt in it, no need for salt at the rim.
  9. Use your discarded lemon half to wet the glass rim, then rim the glass in the dish of pepper.
  10. Fill 4 low ball glasses with ice and add 1 oz. of vodka per glass.
  11. Top off with the Bloody Mary mix and garnish with fresh basil.
  12. Enjoy!

Did you make this recipe?

Share a photo and tag us — we can't wait to see what you've made!

What do you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • majie28
    April 19, 2015

    Omg this is awesome! Been a fan of Bloody Marys for a long time. You should try that one called LAVA ( It’s the best bloody mary mix, I think, since it tastes really good, not to mention, it uses whole non-gmo San Marzano tomatoes and is gluten free. =)

    • thefitchen
      April 20, 2015

      Thanks for the heads up! I’ve never heard of that brand before. I’ll keep an eye out and try it when I see it next!

  • I eat too much papa johns
    December 8, 2014

    I just wanted to tell you I love your recipes! I was originally just looking up pasta squash, but I’ll be trying a couple now.

    I love the simplicity and wallet weary – ness of them all.

    Thank you!